*This man doesn't pay me. I'm promoting his book on my own free will"
I got into LitRPGs through manga honestly. Solo Leveling and stuff like it had me hooked on the whole power progression thing, watching some nobody claw his way up through levels and dungeons until he's untouchable. At some point I realized I was just staring at panels all day and never actually reading anything. So I figured I'd start picking up actual books here and there instead of scrolling through chapters on my phone. LitRPG was the obvious bridge. Same stat blocks, same level ups, same satisfaction of watching a character get stronger in a way you can actually track. Just with words instead of art carrying the weight.
I've read a stack of them at this point, but nothing has hit like Dungeon Crawler Carl.
The Premise Is Stupid In the Best Way
Here's the setup for book one, no spoilers past that since that's as far as I'm letting myself talk about right now even though I'm on book five and dying to bring up stuff that happens later.
Earth gets demolished by an alien mega corporation to make way for the galaxy's newest hit reality show, a dungeon crawl. Every building on the planet gets replaced with a seventeen level dungeon, and every surviving human gets shoved inside as a contestant. The whole thing is broadcast across the universe for entertainment. Our guy Carl survives because he was outside walking his ex girlfriend's cat, Princess Donut, at exactly the wrong moment. So now he's stuck crawling a dungeon with a cat that can talk, using a hastily made ass level, trying not to die on camera in front of billions of alien viewers.
That's it. That's the pitch. And it should not work as well as it does.
Why It Works
Most LitRPGs treat the game system as the whole point. Numbers go up, that's the appeal, the plot is basically a delivery mechanism for the next stat increase. Dungeon Crawler Carl uses the system but never lets it become the reason you're reading. The system is a leash. The real story is a guy who used to be nothing special getting dropped into the worst possible situation and being funny and stubborn enough to survive it anyway.
The humor is doing a lot of heavy lifting too. Carl is sarcastic in a way that feels earned instead of written in. He's not quipping because the author needs comic relief, he's quipping because that's clearly how this guy processes the fact that his entire planet just got turned into a game show set. And Donut, the cat, somehow ends up being one of the best characters in the book despite being, again, a cat.
What really got me though is the worldbuilding around the show itself. The idea that there's an audience out there, betting on outcomes, deciding whether Carl lives or dies based on ratings, gives the whole thing a layer most crawler LitRPGs skip. It's not just a dungeon. It's reality TV with a body count, and the show producers are characters in their own right, manipulating the dungeon to keep things interesting. That's a smart move in my opinion. It gives external stakes to a genre that usually only cares about internal ones.
Where It Sits In the Genre
If you've read other LitRPGs you know the genre has a formula problem. A lot of these books feel interchangeable. Guy gets isekai'd or system'd, guy grinds, guy becomes overpowered, repeat. Dungeon Crawler Carl clearly knows the formula and is having fun subverting it instead of just running it straight. Carl isn't a chosen one. He's not secretly the strongest bloodline. He's a guy with a cat and a bad attitude who keeps getting lucky and smart in roughly equal measure.
I'm five books deep now and the scope keeps expanding in ways book one doesn't even hint at. I'm not going to spoil where it goes, but I'll say this. If you liked book one, the ride does not slow down.
Bottom Line
If you've been circling the LitRPG genre and don't know where to start, or if you're already a fan and somehow haven't picked this one up yet, start with Dungeon Crawler Carl. It's funny, it's got actual stakes, and the cat is better written than most human side characters I've read this year.
Now if you'll excuse me, I've got book six waiting.
0 comments